Why Buy From Maguire Toyota of Grand Island

Car Shopping Made Easy

We provide a vast selection of new and used vehicles, exceptional car care and customer service with a smile!

View Our Inventory

Exceptional Customer Service

We are committed to providing amazing customer experiences.

Meet Our Staff

We Keep You Going

Our service center is here to help ensure you enjoy many great years of driving with the vehicle you purchase from us.

Schedule Service

Thoughtful Amenities

Whether you are waiting for your vehicle to get serviced, picking up a part for your vehicle, or stopping by to check out a new vehicle for yourself, we offer a wide range of amenities to enhance your experience here! Come by, look around and check what we can offer you!

New Inventory

Shop New Inventory

Pre-Owned Inventory

Shop Pre-Owned Inventory

Service Department

Explore Service Department

Parts Department

Explore Parts Department
  1. Maguire Toyota of Grand Island

    1974 Alvin Road
    Grand Island, NY 14072

    • Sales: (716) 404-6004
Loading Map...

Get in Touch

  • Contact our Sales Department at: (716) 404-6004
  • Monday9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Tuesday9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Wednesday9:00AM - 6:00PM
  • Thursday9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Friday9:00AM - 6:00PM
  • Saturday9:00AM - 5:00PM
  • SundayClosed

The staff at Maguire Toyota of Grand Island is proud to serve the drivers of Grand Island, Buffalo, and Niagara Falls, NY. Each day, we look forward to meeting drivers from across the region here at our location. We want to make you a part of our family.

Our goal is to provide you with the best possible car ownership experience. Whether buying or leasing, we work hard to ensure your satisfaction.

Toyota Inventory

Thanks to our always-evolving inventory, you'll be able to choose from the latest new and used Toyota models. You might be looking at the Toyota RAV4, known for its versatility and cargo space. The Toyota Camry carries a powerful available V6 engine capable of transforming a sedan. The Toyota Tacoma has towing capability and a range of interior amenities designed to be intuitive and engaging.

The prices you see will be the prices you get. There are no hidden costs or fees tacked on to the final price, and all discounts and incentives are included. In addition to that, our sales professionals are non-commissioned. That means they're paid based on your satisfaction, not on how much the car costs. They focus on your needs and what you're looking for.

Browse our inventory online, or stop by the dealership to see our current options.

Financing a Car

Once you've gone for a test drive and had the opportunity to get a feel for how a car handles, you may be thinking about getting behind the wheel for good. That means it's time to sit down with our financial professionals to discuss a loan or lease.

If you have an existing car you're considering trading in, use the trade-in tool on our website to get a value of it. We'll always provide a complete appraisal of your vehicle in-person at the dealership to give a final value. That money can be used towards the purchase of that next car.

Start the process by filling out a finance application on our website. It takes just a few minutes, but it gives our staff a leg up when it comes to working on a loan or lease.

Comprehensive Automotive Service

When it comes to vehicle service, our maintenance professionals are here for you. While service isn't always the most exciting topic to talk about for people, it's something that needs to be done to ensure the long-term health of your car.

We go a step further by offering express service. A range of services, like oil changes, tire rotations, battery tests, wiper blade replacement, and coolant checks, can be performed with no appointment necessary. However, you can schedule an appointment on our website at your convenience for a service visit.

Visit Maguire Toyota of Grand Island Today

Maguire Toyota of Grand Island looks forward to having the opportunity to serve those near Grand Island, Buffalo, and Niagara Falls, NY. If you're searching for that next car or need service for your current one, we're here for you.

What Our Recent Customers Say


Published reviews may not represent all experiences of a given dealer based on the dealer’s configuration. For more information, please contact the dealer. Reviews that contain content that is untrue, illegal, obscene, threatening or a violation of any third party’s right, or contains software viruses, solicitations, political campaigns, or any form of “spam” may be removed.